top of page

New Draft: Subjectivity

  • Writer: Malte Willer
    Malte Willer
  • Jun 5, 2019
  • 1 min read

It took a while, but a draft of my "Evidence, Attitudes, and Counterstance Contingency: Toward a Pragmatic Theory of Subjective Meaning" (conspired with Chris Kennedy) is now available at semanticsarchive.net (links). The abstract is as follows:

This paper focusses on two cross-linguistically robust interpretive and distributional characteristics of subjective predicates that have resisted a comprehensive analysis: subjective predicates introduce experiential evidential requirements, and they differ from objective predicates in their distribution under certain types of propositional attitude verbs. The goal of this paper is to argue that these features can be derived in a uniform way, without introducing special kinds of meanings or interpretive operations for subjective predicates, and within a broadly truth-conditional approach to semantic content, given a view of subjective language as an essentially pragmatic, context-sensitive phenomenon. Specifically, we propose that what renders an issue subjective in discourse is speakers' awareness of counterstances: alternative information states that reflect conflicting decisions as to how semantic underdetermination is resolved in context. We show how a characterization of subjective predicates as counterstance contingent expressions not only derives their distributional properties, but also explains why their use comes with distinct evidential requirements.

Recent Posts

See All
Subjectivity

My overview article on subjectivity has now appeared in print, in The Oxford Handbook of Contemporary Philosophy of Language, along with...

 
 
Chicago Area Philosophy Exchange

There is an exciting new iniative here at UChicago Phil: the Chicago Area Philosophy Exchange (CAPHE). Its goal is to foster...

 
 
Credences for Strict Conditionals

My long-in-the-making attempt at explaining how proponents of a strict analysis of conditionals can make sense of probabilities of...

 
 

©2009–2025 Malte Willer. All rights reserved.

[Imprint]

bottom of page